Podcast: Play in new window | Download
Listen to the sermon by clicking the play button above.
Andrea McDaniel
November 15, 2026
First UU Church of Austin
4700 Grover Ave., Austin, TX 78756
www.austinuu.org
Andrea McDaniel explores the tension between anger and accountability, compassion and empathy through the case of Nidal Hasan and the death penalty. Drawing her experience in the military and Unitarian Universalism, she asks how curiosity and empathy can help us respond to violence without abandoning our UU values.
Welcome
Chalice Lighting
This is the flame we hold in our hearts as we strive for justice for everyone. This is the light we shine upon systems of oppression until they are no more. This is the warmth we share with one another as our struggle becomes our salvation.
Call to Worship
A call to worship is secretly a call to focus our attention. Choosing to focus our attention is countercultural. Daily, we are called to worship at the altar of many devices. Surveillance systems we let take lead over every waking moment.
We are called by headlines set purely on our activation and by tools that gamify our every human connection. We are not called, we are led. We are not led, we are entrapped.
Instead, here, we practice being called. We are called to bring our attention to the altar of unpredictable human relatedness. We are called by these ancestors, this wood, this room’s particular light, this chalice’s particular fire, and these children.
We are called to focus our attention on a foolhardy and openhearted commitment to share a future together we cannot cancel nor control.
In the words of poet farmer Wendell Berry, “We are called here to do something today that does not compute.”
Spirit of life, call our collective attention to this precise moment, the threshold between then and now, the moment upon which we hang our honest promises like portraits, chiseled and framed by our own hands, imperfectly and together.
Come, let us worship together.
– Samantha Wilson
Affirming Our Mission
Together we nourish souls, transform lives, and do justice to build the Beloved Community.
Reading
And I think before I begin this reading, there are two terms in here that you may not know if you are a civilian. The first one is ACU, which stands for Army Combat Uniform. The other is multi-cam, which is a form of camouflage that’s pretty advanced and typically worn by special forces. So with that in mind.
WHEN LONELY PRESS LEFT PAW
Army Chaplain George TygerMy son has sent me a Build-A-Bear, dressed in the latest digital camouflage ACUs. Build-A-Bear hasn’t yet caught up with multi-cam. It came with a note in my eight-year-old handwriting, press left paw for I love you and I miss you. Sure enough, when I pressed the left paw, my son’s voice announces, “I love you and I miss you.”
I set the bear on my green army field desk. The bear arrived when I was weary of work and devotion to duty. Unlike the typical day stateside that comes with a beginning, 0630 and an end, 1700, the days on deployment are not so easily demarcated.There is no home to go to, only a cot and a tent just yards from where you work.
I walk home every night to a tiny room 7 by 9 feet with a single light. No one is there waiting for me. No one welcomes me at the end of my day. Work continually expands to fill whatever space is available. Nights alone can drag on. Phone calls home are too short and too distant.
At times like this, we must all focus on what truly matters. Many will try to tell you what that is, but you must decide it for yourself. It’s different for each of us.
Some say that your meaning and purpose have already been determined. They point to a holy book, creed or theology. They say what you are meant to be is contained in those particular words and no other.
But you must choose to accept the book, adhere to the creed or subscribe to the theology. No one can choose it for you. There is no way around it.
There are some values honored by all faith traditions. Compassion in the face of suffering, love in the face of hatred, hope in the face of fear. But on some long lonely nights, what really matters is closer to our hearts than any of these eternal values. Right now, what matters for me is a small stuff bear, dressed in ACUs, and a voice that says, “I love you and I miss you.”
Centering
Music for Meditation: “Cavatina” (Stanley Myers) Valeria Diaz, piano
Sermon
UU FAITH UNDER TENSION
Andrea McDaniel
NOTE: This is a AI generated (edited) transcript.
Please forgive any omissions or errors.
Good morning. I got two out of you, thank you. As your ministerial intern, I’ve gotten to know many of you, but this is a huge congregation. So despite being here since the beginning of the academic year, I am still meeting new people. So I’d like to tell you a little bit about myself.
I am currently attending Austin Presbyterian Theological Seminary, working toward my Masters of Divinity. I love animals and I am currently fostering a very sweet cocker spaniel mix named Sybil. My favorite colors are blue and floral. And yes, I firmly stand by that floral is its own color.
I am a crafter and I love to knit. I am also an active-duty veteran, currently in the Army Reserves in the Chaplain Candidate Program, with my end goal to become an active-duty UU chaplain.
As I was preparing to give a lovely sermon on curiosity, the United States government handed me a different, more intense topic that couldn’t be ignored. Execution by firing squad for the 2009 Fort Hood mass shooter, Nidal Hasan. I know news of this decision came about a month and a half ago now, but with this being my first sermon, I was preparing early.
Nearly 20 years ago, Army psychiatrist Nidal Hasan committed a horrible deed. He opened fire in the Fort Hood Deployment Preparation Medical Facility, killing 13, injuring 32, and became paralyzed from the waist down in the process of his capture. In the slow manner of the military justice system, he was convicted five years later of 13 counts of premeditated murder and 32 counts of attempted premeditated murder. And his sentence was dismissal from the Army and death.
It is events of this magnitude that make us question our UU faith. Are people who kill others out of hate and fear truly worthy of love and forgiveness? Have they lost the right to life itself?
And most importantly, do we hold the right to take that life from them?
The tension of balancing my military identity with my Unitarian Universalist identity is very real. The military inherently trains for war, though it hopes for peace. War means killing. War means destruction. War means loss on all sides, loss of human life, loss of entire countries and identities as they used to be.
War means othering as a means of justification. They are a threat to our way of life, implying that our way of life is superior and must prevail. Othering as an attempt to ward off the spiritual damage each and every soldier receives when they take a life or witness something that goes against every value they hold dear.
How could I possibly want to be a part of that machine as a UU? I should believe in love at the center, but there is no love at the center of what the military trains for. Is there? I beg to differ.
Joseph Yu, an Episcopal priest, has an incredible and succinct video on the difference between patriotism and nationalism, and I’d like to play that for you now with the help of our wonderful tech team.
I cannot believe I have to be the one to say this, especially in the year of our Lord 2025, but apparently we need to go over the difference between patriotism and nationalism, and yes, there is a difference.
Patriotism is love. It’s gratitude. It’s saying, I care about my country enough to tell the truth about it, to celebrate what’s good and work to fix what’s broken.
Nationalism – That’s idolatry. It says, my nation is the nation, above critique, above others, God’s favorite. And once you slap God’s seal of approval on your flag, congratulations, you’ve just made your country a golden calf.
Patriotism gets you, John Lewis crossing the Edmund Pettus Bridge, demanding America life into its ideals.
Nationalism gets you January 6th, with crosses and the Confederate flags in the same mob.
Patriotism says, I love my family enough to admit when we’ve messed up, and I will help us grow.
Nationalism says, my family is perfect, everyone else is trash, and if you disagree, you are out.
One is honest love, the other is toxic possession, one builds, the other bullies. And if you can’t tell the difference, well, bless your heart, because you’re not fully using the brain God gave you, because it’s clearer than clear, that Jesus never called us to worship a flag – only to love our neighbor.
I am married, and my spouse is active duty and has served over 21 years. He has had over five combat tours and continues to lead his juniors with positive mentorship and discipline. I could not be more proud of him and all that he’s accomplished.
Why am I taking the time to point this out right now? He does what he does out of love for his country and his comrades. He leads by example with integrity and always stands up for what is right, especially when he sees something is wrong.
He has received many messages from past soldiers thanking him for his leadership and his integrity, saying that they wouldn’t be where they are today without his leadership.
While in the army, I have served with many immigrants from all around the world, and they are some of the most patriotic people I have ever met. They, like my husband, truly love this country and they appreciate what our armed forces did for them and their home countries. But that does not mean in any way, shape or form, that they don’t see the flaws in the US.
My goal today is not to magically get you all to agree on some point of view regarding the execution of Nidal Hasan. Not at all. We humans can hardly ever agree on simple things, let alone complex issues. Instead, my goal today is to stretch your UU faith just a little bit and see how there might be different perspectives even in this very room.
There are veterans here who joined out of duty to their nation. There are veterans who joined for the many benefits and opportunities that service can offer. And there are people who have actively protested every war since Vietnam or even dodged drafts.
We just set our mission statement at the beginning of service. And if that mission statement right there doesn’t embody patriotism, I truly don’t know what does. We know that harm has been done. We don’t hide from it. Instead, we work to fix it. And we love that we can fix it.
I chose Joseph Yu’s video in particular because we live in a country whose leadership claims we are a Christian nation. Yet the attitude of the current legislation is attempting to erase all the flaws of our nation. Set us up on a high pedestal, look down on all considered other and cast judgment. And that’s not very Christian at all.
In a way, they are attempting to idolize and radicalize our nation. But since it’s white Christianity, that’s perfectly acceptable, right?
Whenever there’s any kind of sensational news, no matter the news outlet or political party, I always ask what’s happening elsewhere? What’s happening behind us while the finger is being pointed here and there?
Why Nidal Hasan and why now? There are three other former US service members awaiting the death penalty. One of whom, Ronald Gray, has been waiting since 1988 for a series of heinous crimes. His execution received presidential approval in 2008, but was stayed by the federal court a few months later and he is still waiting. What’s the difference here?
To make it clear, I am not arguing for the death of any of these men, while they have committed horrific acts against their fellow humans. I’m making a point regarding who decides how and when it’s okay to take a human life.
I’d like you to take a leap of Unitarian Universalist faith with me. Happy, contented, and fulfilled people are not easily radicalized. It’s nearly impossible to walk up to someone who has an excellent job, where they feel fulfilled, a wonderful home life with their family, hobbies they enjoy, and say, “Hey, could I interest you in betraying your country and all of your values today? Let’s go kill some innocent people.”
Now that’s very simplified, of course, but that is the essence of radicalization. You find someone who is deeply struggling, someone who feels ostracized and hated, and you manipulate those feelings of fear, shame, and hatred to your own ends to hurt others.
Nidal Hasan was Muslim in the US post-911, when Islamophobia was at an all-time high. He was Muslim in the armed forces when we were fighting an enemy who allegedly held the same faith as him. I say allegedly because saying that all Muslims hold the same beliefs is like saying all UUs have the same beliefs. And we know that’s not true.
The people the US military engaged with in the Middle East were blanket labeled as Muslims, and some in the media turned the word into a dirty, all-encompassing, othering word that was interchangeable with the word terrorist.
In interviews after the shooting, several people recalled that he had said he was bullied for being Muslim at work. He was met with ignorance and hatred by the very people he worked with, who all joined the military to serve their country, including Nidal.
Another source said that he was terrified of war, due to the stories he had heard from soldiers who returned home. Remember, he was a psychiatrist, so he probably heard some very dark and very scary stories. Long before the shooting, while he was going through his army medical training years prior, he had expressed concerning viewpoints up to and including the possibility of Muslim soldiers deserting or taking the lives of fellow Muslims.
What if these expressions of fear throughout his military career had not been ignored or vilified, but instead met with curiosity and empathy? What if someone had said, what I hear in your words is a fear of war, which is valid considering all you’ve heard from your patients with PTSD. What can I do to help you through this?
Maybe in the course of that conversation, they would learn that his parents died before he was 20, and he did not have much local family support after they died. Maybe they would learn he wouldn’t have a bear’s paw to squeeze to remind him that he’s loved. Maybe they would learn more about the root causes of his slowly radicalizing faith. But we’ll never know because that didn’t happen.
I will not lie to you regarding the tension in my heart and my mind. When I first heard that Nidal Hasan’s death had received military approval, my military side thought, good.
He broke the code, you don’t kill your fellow service members, we are in this together. At the very same moment, my Unitarian Universalist side was disgusted with me. How dare you approve the death of another human being?
He murdered 13 people and nearly killed 32 more. For what? Being a widow skilled? Everyone deploying feels fear, and they feel internal conflict, and no one else is shooting people up. What he did was deplorable. Yes, there is no question about that. He was paralyzed during his capture, and he’s been in prison for 20 years.
I can’t say if he’s being punished enough, or if life in prison is enough, but who are we to say who lives and who dies? Who are we to put this man in front of a firing squad? How does that make us any better than him, or any better than the other countries that we frown upon for being barbaric with executions? It doesn’t.
But both voices inside of me celebrated unanimously at the good news of the cancellation of the live stream for his execution. Both voices celebrated that enough people in our country saw how wrong that was, even the people who were directly impacted by the shooting, and they all spoke up to stop it. Thank God, I thought.
How can I be UU with that internal dialogue I just had? I think it’s perfectly valid to be angry that Nidal felt that he had the right to end 13 lives just because he didn’t want to deploy. I think it’s valid to be angry about the levels of violence that exist in the world, period.
I think that anger is a reflection of the hurt that we feel as UUs who love so deeply that it becomes a personal affront to us when someone commits such a great act of violence as a mass shooting. That anger moves us to action to try and change the world for the better.
Anger about the genocide of Jews in Europe moved the Unitarian Service Committee to rescue refugees from Nazi-occupied Europe. When we are angry that the government tries to take rights away from people, acting as if rights are pie, and if we give a slice to others, there won’t be any rights left for moi, then we are called to act, and we protest, and we make our presence known at the Capitol.
The important thing is that we channel our anger toward our values. I think being outraged that Nidal murdered 13 of my fellow service members and attempted to murder 32 others is UU.
I think that checking my anger into empathy and compassion is UU.
I think feeling conflicted about having been moved to empathy for a murderer is UU.
I think reminding myself that empathy is not approval, but instead it is a hope that we can prevent these acts from happening in the future is UU.
I think all of the conflict that is welling up in my heart around this entire situation is UU, because Unitarian Universalist faith is a faith that is willing and allows us to question ourselves, and it is a faith under constant tension.
Extinguishing the Chalice
We extinguish this flame, but not the light of truth, the warmth of community, or the fire of commitment. These we hold in our hearts until we are together again.
Benediction
May you grow in grace when you feel inner conflict. May you grow in wisdom as you explore your discomfort. And may you grow in love as you follow your UU faith, constantly under tension.
Go in peace and love. Blessed be.
Most sermons during the past 26 years are available online through this website. Click on the index link above to find tables of all sermons for each year listed by date (newest to oldest) with topic and speaker. Click on a topic to go to that sermon.
Podcasts of this and other sermons are also available for free on iTunes. You can find them by clicking on the podcast link above or copying and pasting this link. https://itunes.apple.com/podcast/first-unitarian-universalist/id372427776
